City Island Diner Menu
Welcome to City Island Diner, a hidden gem nestled at 304 City Island Ave, NY. This diner captures the heart of comfort food with a vibrant menu that appeals to all palates. Highlights include delectable breakfast muffins, crispy potato pancakes, and their signature sandwiches like the classic BLT and Pastrami on Rye.
- Delivery and Takeout: Perfect for those on the go.
- Vegetarian Options: A variety for plant-based diners.
- Family-Friendly: Ideal for gatherings, complete with outdoor seating.
As you indulge in the Buttermilk Chicken Tenders paired with housemade ranch or the exquisite Coconut Shrimp, feel the vibrant atmosphere filled with laughter and community spirit. The full bar and ample TV screens ensure a lively experience for gatherings, while the diner’s cozy vibe makes it perfect for kids and groups alike. Enjoy a delightful culinary journey at City Island Diner!
Breakfast Eggs
2 Eggs Any Style
Served with home fries and toast.
Eggs with Bacon, Ham or Sausage
Served with home fries and toast.
Turkey Sausage & Eggs
Served with home fries and toast.
Irish Bangers & Eggs
Served with home fries and toast.
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs
Served with home fries and toast.
Cheeseburger & Eggs
Served with home fries and toast.
The Binge
3 eggs, bacon, ham, and sausage. Served with home fries and toast.
Egg on a Roll Sandwich
Egg & Cheese on a Roll Sandwich
Peppers & Eggs Sandwich
Double Egg on a Roll Sandwich
Egg w/ Bacon, Ham or Sausage Sandwich
Potatoes & Eggs Sandwich
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Bagel & Lox Sandwich
Breakfast Egg Sandwiches
Breakfast Omelettes
Main Mast Omelette
Ham, tomato, and Mozzarella. Served with home fries and toast.
Mizzen Omelette
Spinach, bacon, and Ricotta. Served with home fries and toast.
Rigger Omelette
Sausage, onion, and American cheese. Served with home fries and toast.
Sailmaker Omelette
Bacon, onion, peppers, and cheese. Served with home fries and toast.
Schooner Omelette
Spinach, Feta, and tomato. Served with home fries and toast.
Tender Omelette
Bacon, tomato, and Cheddar. Served with home fries and toast.
Fos'cil Omelette
Tomato, basil, and Ricotta. Served with home fries and toast.
El Nino Omelette
Pepper Jack cheese and salsa. Served with home fries and toast.
West Wind Omelette
Mushroom, onion, and tomato. Served with home fries and toast.
South Wind Omelette
Pastrami, onion, and Swiss. Served with home fries and toast.
Western Omelette
Ham, peppers, and onions. Served with home fries and toast.
Starboard Omelette
Turkey, red peppers, and Mozzarella. Served with home fries and toast.
Hurricane Omelette
Homemade chili, Cheddar, and sour cream. Served with home fries and toast.
Man Overboard Omelette
Everything but the kitchen sink. Served with home fries and toast.
Customized Omelette
Choose up to 3 items from our selection of cheeses, meats, and veggies. Served with home fries and toast.
Quiche Du Jour
With salad. Served with home fries and toast.
Golden Brown Pancakes
Short Stack Pancakes
2 pancakes.
Whole Wheat Pancakes
Whole Wheat Short Stack
2 pancakes.
Blueberry Pancakes
Challah French Toast
Whole Wheat French Toast
Stuffed French Toast
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Breakfast Griddle
Breakfast Muffins & Toast
Toast w/ Butter
Bagel
Toasted. Subject to availability. Call the restaurant for daily selection.
Homemade Muffins
Toasted. Subject to availability. Call the restaurant for daily selection.
Roll w/ Butter
Toasted.
Banana Breads
Pastries
Subject to availability. Call the restaurant for daily selection.
Side of Bacon
Side of Ham
Side of Sausage
Breakfast Sides
Starters
Wings
Served with your choice of wing sauce.
Soft Pretzels
With beer cheese.
Potato Pancakes
With homemade apple chutney.
Buttermilk Chicken Tenders
With house-made ranch.
Coconut Shrimp
With bang bang sauce.
Fresh Zucchini Chips
With homemade ranch.
Nachos Grande
With homemade salsa.
Quesadillas
Homemade Empanadas
Choice of beef and Cheddar, chicken chipotle, or black bean and Goat cheese.
Baked Clams Oreganato
Crispy Calamari
Our Famous Chili Soup - Cup
Our Famous Chili Soup - Bowl
Chili Soup
With cheese, onions, and chips.
Homemade Soup Du Jour - Cup
Please call the restaurant to ask about daily options.
Homemade Soup Du Jour - Bowl
Please call the restaurant to ask about daily options.
Chowders - Cup
Chowders - Bowl
Soups & Chili
Spring Salads
Chicken Caesar Salad
Traditional with house-made croutons.
Crispy Chicken Salad
Breaded chicken, bacon, tomatoes, shredded Cheddar, and housemade ranch.
Traditional Cobb Salad
Bacon, Swiss, tomatoes, and sliced egg.
Chef Salad
Roast beef, turkey, ham, cheese, and sliced egg.
Greek Salad
Traditional.
Spinach Salad
Bacon, sliced egg, mushroom, and red onion.
Roasted Beet Salad
Walnuts, red beets, warm Goat cheese, and red onion.
Antipasto Salad
Breaded eggplant, salami, ham, Mozzarella, and roast pepper.
Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken, bacon, Cheddar, ranch, and bun.
The Mayflower Sandwich
Turkey, stuffing, and cranberry.
Fried Shrimp Tacos
Pico de gallo and slaw.
Filet of Fish on a Bun
With lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and tartar.
Pastrami Reuben
Traditional on rye.
Cubano Panini
Authentic with our special touches.
Pesto Panini
Chicken, roasted peppers, Mozzarella, and pesto.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Spicy breaded chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and Bleu cheese.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Classic with house-made croutons.
Tuna Wrap
White tuna, sliced egg, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Chicken Bruschetta Panini
Breaded cutlet, Mozzarella, marinated tomatoes, and onions.
Sandwiches, Wraps & Paninis
Diner Basics
BLT
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Pastrami on Rye Sandwich
Turkey BLT
Wisconsin Dogs
2 sabrettes dogs with bacon, onions, Cheddar, and fries.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Served with choice of coleslaw or macaroni salad.
Wexford Fancy Grilled Cheese
Ham, tomatoes, onions, and Cheddar on Italian rustica.
Balboa Sandwich
Roast beef with sauteed onions, Mozzarella, and brown gravy on garlic bread. Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Served with French fries or mashed potatoes.
Roast Pork & Pepper Jack Sandwich
Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.
Aunt Frannie's Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.
Hot Heros
Hot Opens Sandwich
Open-faced Meatloaf Sandwich
Served with mashed potatoes.
Open-faced Roast Beef Sandwich
Served with mashed potatoes.
Open-faced Roast Turkey Sandwich
Stuffing, cranberry, and mashed potatoes.
Open-faced Roast Pork Sandwich
Served with mashed potatoes.
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Served with a choice of coleslaw, macaroni salad, or French fries.
Turkey Burger with Salad
Black Bean Veggie Burger
Served with salad.
Burgers
Specialty Burgers
South Western Burger
Homemade chili and Cheddar. Served with coleslaw and fries.
Make Your Own Burger
Your choice of 3 Ingredients. Your choice of 3 Ingredients. Served with coleslaw and fries.
Da Bronx Burger
American cheese, bacon, and sauteed onions. Served with coleslaw and fries.
Great Lakes Burger
Swiss cheese, sauteed mushrooms, and onions. Served with coleslaw and fries.
Thanksgiving Dinner
With all the trimmings. Served with soup or salad.
Roast Loin of Pork
With potato pancakes and sauerkraut. Served with soup or salad.
Roast Beef Dinner
Like grandma made! Served with soup or salad.
Famous Meatloaf Dinner
With mashed potato and veggies. Served with soup or salad.
Chicken Francaise
Served with soup or salad.
Irish Shepard's Pie
Served with soup or salad.
Bangers & Mashed
Served with soup or salad.
Fried Shrimp Basket
Served with soup or salad.
Traditional Fish & Chips
Served with soup or salad.
Broiled Filet Oreganato
Served with soup or salad.
Chicken Marsala
Served with soup or salad.
Chicken Parmigiana
Served with soup or salad.
Homestyle Dinners
Sides
Fries
Disco Fries
Onion Rings
Macaroni Salad
Pint.
Coleslaw
Pint.
