Welcome to City Island Diner
At City Island Diner, located at 304 City Island Ave, the charm of a classic American diner meets a vibrant culinary twist. Known for its extensive menu, this beloved establishment excels in sandwiches, wraps, and hearty breakfast options, all crafted with care. From the crispy Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich to the nostalgic Pastrami Reuben, every dish highlights quality ingredients and bold flavors. With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, City Island Diner is perfect for families and groups alike. Offering delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, it’s a delightful spot to enjoy comforting food amidst the coastal vibe of City Island.
City Island Diner: Reviews & Ratings
A delicious breakfast on City Island. I love this place! Just amazing home cooking and a great staff. Feels like youre on a Cape Cod vacation . Its a wonderful environment. Friendly service .This is the place for an Amazing breakfast or lunch to start your day...Comfort food... I shall return. ... 5 stars here !! Thank you
Cycled 40 miles from south shore Long Island. Got here 9 am and not much options in the area. ...
We went to celebrate a birthday with small dog in tow. The establishment sat us outside the patio looking over beautiful water view. Provided nice choice of appetizers and several different breads to nosh on. We ordered spaghetti with clams ...
I had breakfast here today. The servers Jennifer and James are very nice and go out of their way to help you. ...
Id been looking forward to visiting this place for literally years, since I saw the Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee episode, and I was not disappointed. Cozy community spot with lots of beautiful energy and good vibes. The staff know ...
Fast, friendly and reasonable prices. Their Chicken Caesar Salad is one of the best Ive ever had.
I love that its local! Ive already been here twice with my family. The services waa excellent, the food was flavorful, and the coffee was perfect. The waitresses and waiters are wholesome and kind. Please try their homemade olive almond cake it is outstanding! Look forward to going back next month! Supporting local business.
Sime but Excellent home style menue. Soup Burger and Sandwich Very tasty Specials too. Staff attentive courteous Quaint spot. ...
Location
-
304 City Island Ave City Island, NY 10464 United States Hotline: (718) 885-0362
Welcome to City Island Diner, where the charm of a classic American diner meets the picturesque waters of City Island, New York. This unclaimed gem is not just a place to grab a bite; it’s a destination for lovers of hearty, homestyle cuisine.
Located at 304 City Island Ave, City Island Diner invites you to indulge in a wide array of delicious offerings—from savory sandwiches to satisfying burgers and classic homestyle dinners. It’s the perfect spot for breakfast or lunch, with many vegetarian options that ensure everyone leaves happy.
- Sandwich Lovers: You cannot miss their openfaced sandwiches, each served with creamy mashed potatoes. Try the Openfaced Meatloaf Sandwich or the Openfaced Roast Turkey Sandwich for a taste of nostalgic comfort.
- Burger Enthusiasts: The Cheeseburger Deluxe and Black Bean Veggie Burger are both fantastic choices, paired with a side of coleslaw or fries.
- Homestyle Dinners: Experience a Thanksgiving feast any day with the Thanksgiving Dinner, replete with all the trimmings. Or go for the Famous Meatloaf Dinner, which feels like a warm hug from grandma.
City Island Diner also offers a variety of utilities to enhance your dining experience. Whether you want to enjoy a meal on their outdoor patio or stay connected with their free Wi-Fi, this diner checks all the boxes. Plus, with options for takeout and delivery, you can savor their delicious dishes wherever you are.
With its moderate noise level, it's a great choice for groups and families, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The full bar also means you can enjoy a refreshing drink with your meal. You’ll find yourself returning not just for the food but for the familiar atmosphere that makes every visit feel like coming home.
When in City Island, your appetite deserves more than the ordinary. Make your way to the City Island Diner and let their delightful dishes transport you to a place of comfort and satisfaction. Don’t forget to call ahead at (718) 885-0362 to reserve your spot!
